Cold Stone Creamery’s fall lineup is in stores now for 2026, and it skips pumpkin entirely for two comfort flavors: a brand-new graham cracker Creation and a returning banana pudding fan-favorite. The chain rolled the flavors out on social with no formal press release, so here is the full rundown of what is in each.
Cold Stone is calling the fall push “The Cozy Collection.” It pairs one new Creation with one that fans have been asking to bring back, both built around dessert-nostalgia flavors rather than the usual pumpkin spice.
Crumb and Get It (new for 2026)
The new Creation is Crumb and Get It, made with HONEY MAID Graham Cracker Ice Cream, Cookie Dough, HONEY MAID Graham Crackers, and Cookie Butter. It reads like a graham cracker cookie plate turned into an ice cream, with the cookie butter doing the heavy lifting on the sweet side.
Going Bananas for JELL-O Pudding (back by request)
The returning flavor is Going Bananas for JELL-O Pudding, which Cold Stone brought back with a straightforward “Guess who’s back.” It layers JELL-O Banana Cream Pudding Ice Cream with NILLA Wafers, banana, and whipped topping, a scoopable take on classic banana pudding.
No pumpkin this year
What stands out is what is missing. While most chains spent August racing to drop pumpkin spice, Cold Stone went the other way, building its fall menu on banana pudding and graham cracker instead. It is the same not-everything-is-pumpkin thread running through the rest of the season. Our Fall Food and Drinks 2026 guide tracks which chains leaned all the way into pumpkin and which sat it out, and Duncan Hines took a similar nostalgia route by handing its fall baking mixes to Snoopy and the Peanuts gang.
Is Boo Batter back in 2026? Yes, through October 31
Boo Batter is back at Cold Stone Creamery through October 31, 2026, the chain announced on October 1. It’s the chain’s Cake Batter Ice Cream turned pitch black, and it comes as a Creation, a shake, and an ice cream taco. The Treat or Treat Creation mixes Boo Batter Ice Cream with KIT KAT, Halloween OREO Cookies, and M&M’S. The Witches’ Boo Shake blends it with Halloween OREO Cookies, whipped topping, and Spooky Sprinkles. The Boo Batter Ice Cream Taco wraps it in an orange waffle taco coated with chocolate and Spooky Sprinkles. Cold Stone’s announcement doesn’t list prices. At one Los Angeles store on October 1, the three items ran $9 to $11. See the Boo Batter lineup and prices.
Where and when to get them
Both fall flavors are available now for a limited time at Cold Stone Creamery locations, including the shop outside Universal Orlando’s CityWalk.
Frequently asked questions
What are Cold Stone’s fall flavors for 2026? Two Creations: Crumb and Get It (new) and Going Bananas for JELL-O Pudding (returning), which Cold Stone is grouping as The Cozy Collection.
What is in Crumb and Get It? HONEY MAID Graham Cracker Ice Cream, Cookie Dough, HONEY MAID Graham Crackers, and Cookie Butter.
What is in Going Bananas for JELL-O Pudding? JELL-O Banana Cream Pudding Ice Cream, NILLA Wafers, banana, and whipped topping.
Is Boo Batter back this year? Yes. Boo Batter Ice Cream is at Cold Stone Creamery locations through October 31, 2026, as the Treat or Treat Creation, the Witches’ Boo Shake, and the Boo Batter Ice Cream Taco. At one Los Angeles store on October 1, they ran $9 to $11. See the Boo Batter prices.
Does Cold Stone have pumpkin this fall? No. The 2026 fall flavors are banana pudding and graham cracker rather than pumpkin spice.
JELL-O is a registered trademark of Kraft Foods, used with permission. HONEY MAID is a trademark of Mondelez International group, used under license.
