Papa Murphy’s Jack-O Pizza, a take-and-bake pepperoni pizza shaped like a jack-o’-lantern with black olive eyes, is back through October 31 at $10 for a large. A $15 bundle adds chocolate chip cookie dough.
For every chain’s Halloween menu, see my Fall and Halloween Fast Food 2026 guide.
Papa Johns’ Jack-o’-lantern Pizza is back too, starting at $11.99 in the U.S. and $17.99 in Canada, and my jack-o’-lantern pizza guide has eight pumpkin-shaped pizzas side by side, with prices.
Toppings and Crust
The Jack-O Pizza’s crust is shaped like a jack-o’-lantern, and the toppings make the face:
- Dough: Papa Murphy’s scratch-made dough, on Original crust.
- Sauce and cheese: red sauce and whole-milk mozzarella.
- The face: pepperoni for the smile and black olives for the eyes.
Papa Murphy’s sells its pizzas unbaked, so the Jack-O goes into your own oven.
Jack-O Pizza Price and Sizes
- Large: $10.
- Family size: $3 more.
- Dairy-free cheese: $3 more.
- Alaska: prices vary.
The $10 price is the same as last October, when Papa Murphy’s site listed the Jack-O at “Just $10!” The offer’s fine print limits it to Original crust, with no substitutions or added toppings.
“At $10, we’re making it easy for families to bring some Halloween fun to the dinner table without adding more stress or expense to an already busy night,” said Dallas Massey, senior vice president of marketing for Papa Murphy’s.
The Scream of a Deal Bundle
The Scream of a Deal is a large Jack-O Pizza and Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough for $15, or $18 in Alaska.
How to Bake the Jack-O Pizza
Papa Murphy’s gives these baking instructions for an Original crust pizza, the crust the Jack-O comes on:
- Bake it within 60 minutes of purchase, or refrigerate it and take it out 60 minutes before baking. Bake within 24 hours of purchase.
- Preheat the oven to 425 degrees, remove the plastic wrap, and leave the pizza on its tray.
- Bake on the center rack for about 12 to 18 minutes, until the crust is golden brown.
- Let it sit for 5 minutes before cutting.
The cookie dough in the bundle bakes at 350 degrees for 12 to 14 minutes, dropped by rounded tablespoons onto an ungreased baking sheet.
Papa Johns’ Jack-o’-Lantern Pizza Is Back
Papa Johns’ Jack-o’-lantern Pizza is a pumpkin-shaped large thin-crust pizza with pepperoni, olive eyes and cheese, served unsliced with a pepperoncini and a seasoning packet on the side. Its U.S. page lists it again, starting at $11.99, for delivery or carryout at papajohns.com or in the app. It can’t be customized, and the page gives no end date for the U.S.
In Canada, it’s $17.99 at participating Papa Johns restaurants from October 19 through November 1, according to Papa Johns Canada.
Other Halloween Pizzas in 2026
Target sells a take-and-bake pumpkin-shaped pizza for $6 under its Market Pantry label, and a ghost-shaped one at the same price. California Pizza Kitchen has a $5 Jack-O-Lantern Pizza, a 7-inch kids’ pizza, through October 31. Chuck E. Cheese’s Pumpkin-Shaped Pepperoni Pizza is on its Halloween menu through November 1, and a dine-in Boo-Meal Deal built around it starts at $34.99. Tombstone ships a candy corn pizza kit for $1.31.
In New York, Heidi Klum’s Halloween Butterfinger Pizza, a dessert pizza, is on the menu at Crazy Pizza in SoHo from October 1 through 31.
The Jack-O Pizza and the bundle are at participating Papa Murphy’s stores from October 1 through October 31, and the chain has nearly 1,000 U.S. locations. To order, visit papamurphys.com/jack-o.
