Nine of Jellycat’s 19 Halloween plush are sold out, and on eBay two of them cost much more than they did new: Hocus Crow, a $35 plush whose listings marked authentic start at about $109, and Growlston Gargoyle, a $45 gargoyle listed from $68. Five of the sold-out designs are listed for less than Jellycat charged.
Note: I may earn a commission if you buy through some links in this article.
The 2026 collection is 19 designs on Jellycat’s U.S. store, from a $28 Ghost Bob and a smiley jack-o’-lantern named Ooky up to a $70 wizard puppy called Rufferty, with a Broox Bat, a Growlston Gargoyle, and a $30 garlic bulb with a face in between. As of October 19, nine are sold out and 10 are still in stock.
The new Jellycat Halloween plush for 2026
Ten of the 19 designs are new this year. Jellycat’s Halloween range mixes its spooky characters with the brand’s Amuseables line, everyday foods and objects given a stitched-on face. Here is the new-for-2026 group, with prices. Broox Bat and Growlston Gargoyle sold out by October 19, the first of the new designs to go. Amuseables Peanut ‘Cat’ and Ooky Jack O Lantern are marked Out of Stock on Jellycat’s Halloween page, but their product pages still had Add to Bag on October 19.
Also still in stock
Two more designs are in stock as of October 19: Mummy Bob, which returns from the Bob family, and Amuseables Toilet Roll, back in stock again after selling out.
Sold out at Jellycat, and what they cost on eBay
Nine of the collection’s designs are out of stock on Jellycat’s U.S. store as of October 19: Broox Bat and Growlston Gargoyle, new this year, plus seven of the eight that were out on October 10. The eighth, Amuseables Toilet Roll, is back in stock. Here is what each sold-out design was listed for on eBay on October 19, from U.S. sellers offering new plush at a fixed price. These are asking prices, not sold prices.
| Design | Jellycat price | eBay asking price, October 19 |
|---|---|---|
| Hocus Crow | $35 | Listings marked authentic from $109 to $149, plus shipping |
| Growlston Gargoyle | $45 | From $68 to $95, plus shipping |
| Amuseables Toffee Apple | $30 | From $30, plus $6.05 delivery |
| Skeleton Bob | $40 | From $38.95 with free delivery |
| Bartholomew Bear ‘Spider’ | $65 | From $37.04 with free delivery |
| Broox Bat | $38 | From $30, plus $6.59 delivery, for listings titled Jellycat |
| Heccaty Hootnightly | $38 | From $23.59 with free delivery |
| Spookipaws Cat | $38 | From $17.59 with free delivery |
| Lachlan Sad Rat | $35 | From $16.99 with free delivery |
Hocus Crow and Growlston Gargoyle are the two with a real markup. Hocus Crow’s listings marked authentic start at about $109, more than three times its $35 price, and one other Hocus Crow listing sat at $36.66. Growlston Gargoyle is listed from $68 plus shipping, about one and a half times its $45 price. Amuseables Toffee Apple and Skeleton Bob are listed at around what Jellycat charged.
The other five, Bartholomew Bear ‘Spider’, Broox Bat, Heccaty Hootnightly, Spookipaws Cat and Lachlan Sad Rat, are listed for less than Jellycat charged, even though Jellycat itself is sold out. I can’t tell you from a listing whether a plush is real, so read the seller’s feedback and the photos of the tags before you buy. Jellycat’s U.S. site has a store locator if you’d rather check a shop near you first. Skeleton Bob is also listed on Amazon by a third-party seller.
Jellycat has restocked two designs this fall
The 2026 collection spans 19 designs, and nine were sold out on October 19. Two designs came back in September, Amuseables Toffee Apple and Amuseables Toilet Roll, and both sold out again. Toilet Roll is back in stock as of October 19, and Toffee Apple is still sold out. For regular readers, sellouts are a familiar pattern this fall, following the sold-out run on Spirit Halloween’s 6-foot-10 Pennywise animatronic and the limited Snoopy Peanuts glass cold cup at Starbucks.
Which one are you after this year?
Jellycat’s Halloween plush have become a yearly collectible, and the 2026 group keeps to the classics, a ghost, a mummy, a skeleton, a bat, and a gargoyle, alongside the food-with-faces Amuseables. At $28 to $70 apiece, the pieces sit in gift range, which is part of why the popular ones go early.
More Halloween 2026 Retail
For more of this year’s Halloween releases, see our roundups of Halloween blind boxes for 2026, the Build-A-Bear 2026 Halloween collection, and what’s live at Target’s Hyde & EEK! Boutique.
